Bhagat Muthiya Nu Shaak is a lesser-known curry from the state of Gujarat. Deep-fried lentil balls are cooked in a tangy, spicy tomato gravy to create this very flavourful curry that makes for a great pair to rotis, parathas and pooris.
In today’s blog post, I am going to share with you all how to make delectable Bhagat Muthiya Nu Shaak at home. The proceedure is slightly elaborate, but not overly difficult either, and the end result is most definitely worth it!
A Closer Look At Bhagat Muthiya Nu Shaak
Bhagat Muthiya Nu Shaak is a sort of gravy-based kofta curry from Surat, the diamond city of Gujarat. Koftas – or deep-fried dumplings – made from chana dal are cooked in a spiced tomato-and-onion gravy. The end result is a very delicious curry, the koftas having absorbed the beautiful flavours of the gravy, becoming softer and succulent.
I got in touch with the immensely knowledgeable Urvi Zanzmera, blogger from Surat, for some insights on the Bhagat Muthiya Nu Shaak, and she was sweet enough to write back immediately. I gather that this dish is a specialty of the Khatri community of Surat, a class of merchants who are mostly meat-eaters. The vegetarian Bhagat Muthiya Nu Shaak was apparently created specifically for the non-meat-eaters – called ‘bhagats‘ – present at community gatherings like weddings, baby showers and other religious occasions.
While the basic feature of this dish remains the chana dal koftas cooked in gravy, variations to the recipe are often found. Some include potatoes, to thicken the gravy. Some include other vegetables like green peas, sweet corn kernels and purple yam – this latter version is called Veg Tapelu, a vegetarian substitute for the meat-based tapelu that is popularly made during Khatri get-togethers. Some others use soya chunks to make the koftas, to give them a texture similar to meatballs.
The recipe I am going to share today is adapted on the basis of Urvi’s insights on the Bhagat Muthiya Nu Shaak, as well as what I have read about the curry so far. It is a simple version, without the addition of vegetables like potatoes or yam, but every bit delicious and satisfying. I have made little tweaks here and there, to make the curry more appealing to my family, and they did love it to bits.
What Goes Into Bhagat Muthiya Nu Shaak – The Ingredients
Like I was saying earlier, this curry contains koftas or dumplings made from chana dal. Chana dal is first soaked, then ground in a mixer, flavoured with finely chopped onions, ginger and green chillies, spices like carom seeds (ajwain), and sesame seeds. I also like adding in a handful of fenugreek (methi) leaves, which elevate the taste of the koftas greatly. Some gram flour (besan) is used for binding purposes. This mixture is shaped into dumplings, which are deep-fried and then cooked in a tomato-based gravy that also contains onions, ginger and garlic.
I use a bit of garam masala and jaggery in the gravy and a tempering of cumin and carom seeds, to make it tastier, along with the more commonly used roasted coriander powder and roasted cumin powder (together called ‘dhana-jeeru‘ in Gujarati cuisine).
The Bhagat Muthiya Nu Shaak is served with a generous garnish of finely chopped coriander, alongside rotis, parathas or pooris.
How To Make Bhagat Muthiya Nu Shaak
Here is how I make the curry.
Ingredients (serves 4-6):
For the koftas:
1. 3/4 cup chana dal
2. 1-1/2 green chillies
3. A 1-inch piece of ginger
4. Salt to taste
5. 1/4 teaspoon turmeric powder
6. Red chilli powder to taste (optional)
7. About 1-1/2 tablespoons of gram flour or besan (optional)
8. 1/4 teaspoon carom (ajwain) seeds
9. 3/4 tablespoon sesame seeds
10. 1/2 tablespoon jaggery powder
11. A handful of fenugreek (methi) leaves
12. 2 tablespoons finely chopped coriander leaves
13. 1 large onion
14. Oil for deep frying the pakodas
Other ingredients:
1. 1 medium-sized onion
2. 4 medium-sized tomatoes
3. A 1-inch piece of ginger
4. 4-5 cloves of garlic
5. 3/4 tablespoon oil
6. 3/4 teaspoon cumin seeds
7. 1/4 teaspoon carom (ajwain) seeds
8. 2 pinches of asafoetida
9. 1 medium-sized onion
10. Salt to taste
11. 1/4 teaspoon turmeric powder
11. Red chilli powder to taste
12. 3/4 teaspoon roasted coriander powder
13. 1/2 teaspoon roasted cumin powder
14. 1/2 teaspoon garam masala
15. 1/2 tablespoon jaggery powder (optional)
16. 1 tablespoon finely chopped coriander leaves
Method:
We will start by preparing the batter for the koftas.
1. Soak the chana dal in enough water for 2-3 hours. Then, drain out all the water from it.
2. Take the soaked and drained chana dal in a mixer jar. Peel the ginger, chop roughly, and add to the mixer jar. Chop the green chillies roughly and add them in too. Grind everything together coarsely, without adding any water. Transfer this ground mixture to a large mixing bowl.
3. Add salt to taste, turmeric powder, red chilli powder (if using), gram flour, sesame seeds, carom seeds and jaggery powder.
4. Chop the methi greens and coriander finely. Add to the mixing bowl.
5. Chop the onion finely. Add to the mixing bowl. Mix everything well together. We will use this batter to prepare the koftas.
Next, we will prepare the koftas and also do some basic prep required for the sabzi.
6. Heat oil for deep-frying in a heavy-bottomed pan. Let it get nice and hot.
7. In the meantime, peel the onion required for the sabzi. Chop finely.
8. Chop the tomatoes into large pieces and add them to a mixer jar. Peel the garlic cloves and add them in too. Peel the ginger, chop roughly, and add in as well. Grind everything together to a smooth puree.
9. When the oil is nicely hot, reduce flame to medium. Drop in small blobs of the batter we prepared earlier into it, a few at a time. Deep fry them evenly on all sides, till they are brown on the outside and well done on the inside. Take care to ensure that the blobs do not burn while frying. When done, drain out the oil and transfer them to a plate. Use all the batter to fry koftas in a similar manner. Keep aside.
Now, we will prepare the Chana Dal Kofta Curry.
10. Heat 3/4 tablespoon oil in a heavy-bottomed pan. Add in the cumin and carom seeds, as well as the asafoetida. Let them stay in for a few seconds, without burning them. Turn the flame down to medium now.
11. Add the finely chopped onions to the pan. Saute on medium flame for 4-5 minutes or till they start turning brown.
12. Add the tomato puree to the pan, along with a little salt, red chilli powder to taste and turmeric powder. Mix well. Cook on medium flame for 6-7 minutes or till the raw smell of the tomatoes goes away completely. You may add a splash of water if you think the puree is getting too thick.
13. Once the puree has thickened and cooked well, add in the jaggery powder, along with 3/4th to 1 cup of water or as needed to adjust the consistency of the gravy. Mix well.
14. Add the roasted coriander and cumin powder to the pan, as well as the garam masala. Also add in the deep-fried koftas we prepared earlier. Mix gently. Taste and adjust salt as needed.
15. Cook on medium flame for 6-7 minutes or till the gravy has thickened and the kofta have absorbed the flavours from it. You will need to stir intermittently, gently. Switch off gas when the gravy has thickened up, but is still on the runnier side – it will thicken up quite a bit upon cooling.
16. Garnish with finely chopped coriander. Your Bhagat Muthiya Nu Shaak is ready. Leave it undisturbed for 15-20 minutes for the flavours of the gravy to seep into the kofta even better. The shaak is now ready to serve along with rotis or plain parathas.
Tips & Tricks
- Adjust the quantity of green chillies, red chilli powder, jaggery powder, garam masala, roasted coriander and cumin powder, and salt as per personal taste preferences.
- Adjust the quantity of water you use, depending upon the consistency of the gravy you require. Remember that the gravy will thicken up quite a bit upon cooling.
- It is optional to use gram flour (besan). You can add some if your lentil mixture has turned out a tad watery and you are not able to shape koftas out of it. You can totally skip it if not required.
- The onion and garlic in this recipe can be easily skipped, if you do not prefer using them.
- A little bit of jaggery is added to the gravy, to balance out the other flavours. It does not make the gravy too sweet, but in fact, accentuates the other flavours. I would definitely not suggest skipping it.
- Make sure the lentil balls do not break while mixing the gravy. Stir gently while cooking.
- Traditionally, some potatoes are also added to the gravy, along with the chana dal koftas. I have not used potatoes, here – I prefer making this sabzi without potatoes.
- I have pureed the tomatoes, ginger and garlic for the gravy, and have used finely chopped onion. You could puree the onion too, along with the rest of the ingredients for the gravy. Alternatively, you could use finely chopped tomatoes, ginger and garlic in the gravy, along with the onions.
- You can add a few cashewnuts while pureeing the tomatoes, ginger and garlic. This will make the gravy richer, thicker and more flavourful. I have not used any here – the kotfas cooking in the gravy is enough to thicken it.
- It is not customary to add onions and fenugreek (methi) greens to the koftas. I have used them to make the koftas more flavourful.
- I have used home-made roasted coriander and cumin powder here. I make these blends in small batches and keep a ready stock of them in dry air-tight bottles to use as needed. To make the roasted coriander powder – dry roast a handful of coriander (dhania) seeds in a pan on medium heat, for 4-5 minutes or till fragrant, taking care not to burn them. Transfer to a plate, let the seeds cool down completely, then grind to a slightly coarse powder. The technique for making the roasted cumin (jeera) powder is the same – just substitute the coriander seeds for cumin.
- If you have the Gujarati spice blend called dhana-jeeru, you could use it instead of the roasted coriander and cumin powder. Dhana-jiru is a mix of cumin and coriander seed powder, commonly prepared in Gujarati households, easily available in stores in Gujarat too.
- Make sure the chana dal koftas are completely cooked before adding them to the gravy. Fry them in appropriately hot oil, at medium heat, to ensure that they cook evenly.
- This is a completely vegetarian and vegan dish, suited to people following a plant-based diet. If you want to make it gluten-free, skip the asafoetida used in the tempering. Most commercially available brands of asafoetida in India do contain wheat flour, so are best avoided when one is following a gluten-free diet. However, if you can find 100% gluten-free asafoetida, you can definitely use it.
Did you like this recipe? Do tell me, in your comments!